The picks
Best Yarn for Prayer Shawls
Given away, worn by someone unwell, washed by someone who will not read your care note.
By Sawyer V. · Published October 11, 2026
Disclosure: we earn a commission when you buy through the links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never decides what we recommend or how we rank it - read the full disclosure.
The short answer
Use a soft, machine-washable worsted acrylic. A prayer shawl is given to someone who is ill, bereaved or in hospital, and it will be washed by whoever is doing that household's laundry - which rules out hand-wash yarn no matter how lovely it is. Lion Brand Heartland is the best overall pick because it reads as a natural fiber but survives any wash cycle. Choose an anti-pilling acrylic if the shawl will be worn daily for years, and superwash merino only when you know the recipient tolerates wool and the budget allows roughly 1,000 yards. Avoid chenille, untreated wool and anything that sheds.
| # | Product | Best for | Fiber | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Lion Brand HeartlandHeathered acrylic - it reads as a natural fiber at arm's length and goes through a hot wash and a tumble dryer without comment. | A shawl that has to look good and survive any laundry | 100% acrylic, heathered | $13.57 - View on Amazon#ad disclosure - price as of October 11, 2026 |
| 2 |  Caron Simply SoftNoticeably silkier than standard acrylic, with a drape most worsted acrylics do not have. | A shawl worn against the neck for hours during treatment | 100% acrylic | $16.18 - View on Amazon#ad disclosure - price as of October 11, 2026 |
| 3 |  Lion Brand Basic Stitch Anti-PillingSpun specifically to resist pilling - the failure mode that ruins most acrylic shawls. | A shawl that will be worn daily for a long time | 100% acrylic | $5.99 - View on Amazon |
| 4 |  Cascade 220 Superwash MerinoSuperwash merino: breathable and genuinely warm, and it still goes in a machine. | A shawl for someone you know tolerates wool | 100% superwash merino | $21.00 - View on Amazon#ad disclosure - price as of October 11, 2026 |
| 5 |  Bernat BlanketA chenille shawl is heavy, hot, and worms where it rubs a shoulder. It looks right for about a month. | Blankets | 100% polyester chenille | $20.96 - View on Amazon#ad disclosure - price as of October 11, 2026 |
Lion Brand Heartland
Lion Brand · Best for a shawl that has to look good and survive any laundry
A soft all-acrylic worsted in a 5oz skein - a lot of yardage per skein, which matters when a blanket needs eight of them.
- Fiber
- 100% acrylic (solids); 94% acrylic, 6% rayon (tweeds)
- Weight
- 4 Medium / worsted
- Skein
- 5oz / 142g, 251yd / 230m (solids)
- Gauge
- 16 sts x 22 rows on US 9 (5.5mm)
- Hook
- J-10 (6mm), 12 sc x 15 rows
- Care
- Machine wash gentle, tumble dry low, no bleach
Who it suits
Ministry and group knitters making shawls for people they will not see again.
Why it is here
100% acrylic, worsted weight, machine wash and dry. The heathering is what makes this the pick over cheaper acrylics: flat acrylic looks flat, and a gift object is looked at. Meanwhile the washability is not a nicety - a prayer shawl goes to a household in crisis and will be washed by whoever does the laundry, in whatever cycle they use.
What you give up
It is acrylic, so it does not breathe and can feel warm indoors. The heathered palette is muted, which is usually right for this object but limits you if you want a bright color.
Specifications from Lion Brand product page. We have not handled this item - see how we pick.
Caron Simply Soft
Caron · Best for a shawl worn against the neck for hours during treatment
A softer, shinier acrylic worsted with noticeable drape - which is exactly why it is a poor choice for anything that needs to hold a shape.
- Fiber
- 100% acrylic
- Weight
- 4 Medium / worsted
- Skein
- 6oz / 170g, 315yd / 288m
- Gauge
- 18 sts x 24 rows on 5mm (US 8)
- Hook
- 5mm (US H/8), 13 sc x 14 rows
- Care
- Machine wash cool, dry flat, no bleach
Who it suits
Anyone making a shawl for someone who will wear it constantly, especially against sensitive skin.
Why it is here
100% acrylic, worsted weight, machine washable. Its finishing gives a smoother, more lustrous hand and better drape than typical worsted acrylic, which matters on a garment that sits on a neck for hours. It is also one of the most widely stocked yarns in the US, so a group can match a dye lot a year later.
What you give up
Slippery, so stitches slide on the needle and a finished shawl slides off shoulders more readily than a grippier yarn. It also pills with sustained wear.
Specifications from Yarnspirations product page. We have not handled this item - see how we pick.
Lion Brand Basic Stitch Anti-Pilling
Lion Brand · Best for a shawl that will be worn daily for a long time
An acrylic worsted sold specifically on its pilling behavior, which is the one complaint that ends most acrylic garments.
- Fiber
- 100% acrylic
- Weight
- 4 Medium / worsted
- Skein
- 3.5oz / 100g, 185yd
- Gauge
- 18 sts x 26 rows on US 8 (5mm)
- Hook
- H-8 (5mm), 16 sc x 18 rows
- Care
- Machine wash, machine dry
Who it suits
Anyone who has seen a gift shawl go bobbly within months, and anyone making one for long-term daily use.
Why it is here
100% acrylic, worsted weight, machine washable, engineered against pilling. A shawl is worn over clothing and rubs continuously at the shoulders and under the arms, which is exactly where acrylic normally pills. Choosing a yarn built against that is the single biggest thing you can do for how the shawl looks in a year.
What you give up
A slightly firmer, less fluid hand than Simply Soft, so the drape is a little stiffer. The color range is also smaller than the big budget acrylics.
Specifications from Lion Brand product page. We have not handled this item - see how we pick.
Cascade 220 Superwash Merino
Cascade Yarns · Best for a shawl for someone you know tolerates wool
Machine-washable merino at 220 yards to the 100g skein - the standard answer when a sweater pattern says worsted and you want to be able to wash it.
- Fiber
- 100% superwash merino wool
- Skein
- 3.5oz / 100g, 220yd / 200m
- Gauge
- 20 sts x 28 rows in stockinette on US 7
- Weight class
- DK to light worsted
- Care
- Superwash treated - machine washable
Who it suits
Anyone making one for a named person who has said they prefer natural fibers.
Why it is here
100% superwash merino, 220yd per 100g, machine washable. Where acrylic traps heat, wool breathes and regulates, which is a real comfort advantage for someone who is unwell and alternating between too hot and too cold. The superwash treatment keeps it machine washable, which is the non-negotiable here.
What you give up
Several times the price, and a shawl takes 1,000 yards or more - this is the expensive option by a wide margin. It is also out entirely if there is any wool sensitivity, which you often cannot check.
Specifications from Cascade Yarns product page. We have not handled this item - see how we pick.
Bernat Blanket
Bernat · Best for blankets
Polyester chenille at 108 yards to a 150g ball. Fast, warm, machine washable, and it will shed and worm if the tension is loose.
- Fiber
- 100% polyester (chenille)
- Weight
- 6 Super Bulky
- Ball
- 5.3oz / 150g, 108yd / 98m
- Gauge
- 8 sts x 13 rows on 8mm (US 11)
- Hook
- 8mm (US L/11), 7 sc x 8 rows
- Care
- Machine wash delicate, tumble dry gentle
Who it suits
Nobody, for a shawl. It is tempting because it feels wonderful in the shop.
Why it is here
100% polyester chenille at super bulky. A shawl's weight hangs from the shoulders, and chenille is both heavy and structureless, so it drags down and stretches. The pile also worms out of the twist wherever the fabric rubs - and a shawl rubs at the shoulders every time the wearer moves.
What you give up
You give up the plushest fabric available. If you want to give something plush, make a lap blanket instead - [best yarn for a blanket](/yarn-by-project/best-yarn-for-a-blanket) covers it.
Specifications from Yarnspirations product page. We have not handled this item - see how we pick.
Why this is not the fashion shawl page
The site has a best yarn for a shawl page and it gives different answers, because a fashion shawl and a prayer shawl are different objects with different owners.
| Prayer shawl | Fashion shawl | |
|---|---|---|
| Who washes it | A stranger, any cycle | You, carefully |
| Care tolerance | Must be machine wash and dry | Hand wash is fine |
| Fiber priority | Washable, soft, non-allergenic | Drape, halo, beauty |
| Budget | Often many shawls, group-funded | One, can be a treat |
| Availability | Must restock the same shade for years | One-off is fine |
| Typical yarn | Worsted acrylic | Merino, silk, mohair blends |
| Yardage | 900-1,200yd | 400-800yd |
What makes a good one
- Soft against a neck, not just against a hand. Test a washed swatch on your own neck. Hands are a poor judge of prickle.
- Light enough to keep on. A heavy shawl gets taken off. Worsted weight at a relaxed gauge is the usual balance.
- Warm without being hot. Someone unwell often swings between the two. An open stitch pattern in worsted is more adaptable than a dense fabric.
- No fringe, or a short one. Long fringe catches on wheelchair wheels, IV lines and bed rails. Many hospital programs specifically ask for no fringe.
- A color that is not about your taste. Muted heathers, soft neutrals and gentle blues and greens are the usual ministry palette for a reason.
- Dye lot discipline. Buy all of a shawl's yarn at once. If your group makes these continuously, standardize on a yarn that stays in production.
Yardage and group planning
A full-size prayer shawl is typically 60 to 72 inches long and 20 to 24 inches wide, which works out at roughly 900 to 1,200 yards in worsted weight - three to five standard skeins, or one to two of the large value put-ups most budget acrylics come in.
For a group making these continuously, the large put-up is the right purchase: it reduces dye-lot joins within a shawl and makes the per-shawl cost small enough that the group can keep going. How much yarn do I need has the method for calculating from a swatch if your pattern is an unusual size.
Stitch patterns that suit the yarn
- Simple repeats. These are often made in groups with mixed skill levels, and a three-row repeat gets finished.
- Open enough to breathe. A solid worsted fabric is hot. A mesh, a feather-and-fan or a simple lace keeps it adaptable.
- Something that looks the same both sides. A shawl gets flipped constantly on a shoulder, and a wrong side that reads as wrong is a shame.
- Garter or seed stitch if the yarn is slippery. Simply Soft in stockinette slides off a shoulder; a textured surface grips.
- Block it lightly, and only if the yarn responds. Acrylic does not block in the usual sense - what it does under heat is permanent, so be careful.
If you are knitting for an organization rather than an individual, best yarn for charity knitting covers working to a published specification, and best yarn for chemo caps is the matching project most groups make alongside these.
Questions people actually ask
What is the best yarn for a prayer shawl?
A soft, machine-washable worsted acrylic. Lion Brand Heartland is the best all-round choice because its heathering reads as a natural fiber while it survives any wash cycle. An anti-pilling acrylic is better if the shawl will be worn daily for years.
How much yarn do I need for a prayer shawl?
Roughly 900 to 1,200 yards in worsted weight for a 60 to 72 inch shawl - three to five standard skeins, or one to two of the large value put-ups. Buy it all at once so the dye lot matches across the whole piece.
Why do prayer shawl groups use acrylic?
Because of who washes it. The shawl goes to a household dealing with illness or bereavement, and it will be laundered in whatever cycle that house uses, by someone who will not read a care note. Acrylic survives that; wool and hand-wash yarns do not.
Can you use wool for a prayer shawl?
Superwash merino works if you know the recipient tolerates wool and the budget allows - it breathes and regulates temperature better than acrylic, which genuinely helps someone who is unwell. Untreated wool does not, because it felts in a normal wash and the shawl will be destroyed.
Should a prayer shawl have fringe?
Usually not, or only a short one. Long fringe catches on wheelchair wheels, bed rails and IV lines, and many hospital programs specifically request shawls without it. Check the receiving organization's requirements before you start.
What size should a prayer shawl be?
Commonly 60 to 72 inches long and 20 to 24 inches wide, which is big enough to wrap the shoulders and stay put while sitting. If you are making them for a specific organization, use their published dimensions - most ministry and hospital programs publish exact requirements.